When God Sends the Fish: What Stubbornness and Surrender Teach Us About Grace

Rev. Erik Germesin • Rector
August 11, 2026

5 Minute Read

There is a particular kind of stubbornness that most of us recognize in ourselves, even if we would rather not admit it. It shows up when we grip the steering wheel a little tighter and insist we know the way, even as the road grows unfamiliar. It shows up when the gas light comes on and we think, surely I can make it. It shows up in our relationships, our careers, our spiritual lives, and our prayers. We act first, then expect God to bless whatever we have already decided to do.

The ancient story of Jonah is not simply a strange tale about a man and a large fish. It is a mirror. And if we look into it honestly, most of us will recognize the face staring back.

Running in the Wrong Direction

Jonah was a prophet, a man who heard from God. And yet when God called him to go to Nineveh, a city full of people Jonah considered enemies, he turned and went the opposite direction. He did not just hesitate or delay. He boarded a ship headed as far from his calling as the known world would allow. His refusal was not born of ignorance. It was born of pride and prejudice. He knew what God wanted. He simply decided that God was wrong about who deserved mercy.

The storm that followed was not random bad weather. The sailors on that ship eventually understood something supernatural was at work. And Jonah, to his credit in that moment, admitted the truth. The storm was his fault. He was thrown overboard, and a great fish swallowed him whole.

What happens next is remarkable. From inside the belly of the fish, in a place the scriptures describe as the realm of the dead, Jonah prays. Not a polished, formal prayer. A waterlogged, desperate cry from a man who has run out of options. He says in Jonah 2 that when his life was fading away, he remembered the Lord, and his prayer reached God's holy temple. Even there, in the dark and the stench and the impossibility of the moment, God heard him.

The fish, it turns out, was not a punishment. It was a rescue. Jonah should have drowned. Instead, he was carried. God would rather send a disruptive, uncomfortable, even terrifying mercy than watch someone sail quietly into their own destruction.

Eyes on the Storm

The Gospel of Matthew gives us a companion story in Peter walking on water. The disciples are in a boat at night, being battered by waves, when they see Jesus walking toward them on the sea. Peter, in a moment of extraordinary courage and faith, asks Jesus to call him out onto the water. Jesus says one word: come.

And Peter goes. He actually steps out of the boat and walks on water toward Jesus. This is not a small thing. This is faith in action, the holy kind of stubbornness that refuses to stay safe when Jesus is calling you forward.

But then Peter looks around. He sees the wind. He feels the waves. He becomes suddenly, acutely aware that he is a human being standing on water in the middle of a storm, and human beings do not do that. And he begins to sink.

The Greek word used in Matthew 14 for his sinking describes being pulled down into the depths, swallowed by the waves. In an instant, Peter goes from walking on water to drowning. Not because he lacked faith entirely, but because he shifted his gaze. He stopped looking at Jesus and started looking at the storm.

The Same Three Words

Here is what is striking when you place these two stories side by side. Jonah sinks because of deliberate rebellion. Peter sinks because of distracted self-reliance. One man is running from God. The other is reaching toward him but loses focus. The circumstances are different. The internal postures are different. And yet both men end up in the same place: underwater, out of options, desperate.

And both men are saved by the same prayer.

Jonah cries out to God from the belly of the fish. Peter cries out, Lord, save me. Three words. No explanation, no defense, no lengthy confession. Just a cry for help. And in both cases, God answers immediately. The fish carries Jonah to dry land. Jesus reaches out his hand and pulls Peter up before he can sink any further.

Whether you sink through active rebellion or distracted pride, the grace of God reaches to the exact same depth.

What Is Your Fish?

It is worth sitting with an uncomfortable question. What storm or fish is present in your life right now that you have been treating as random bad luck or unfortunate circumstance? What if God is stubbornly using that disruption to stop the runaway train of your pride?

Sometimes our anxieties, our burnout, our relational wreckage, our seasons of restlessness are not simply the result of a hard world. Sometimes they are the mercy of a God who loves us too much to let us keep sailing in the wrong direction. Hitting rock bottom has a way of clearing our vision. When we reach the edge of our own strength and ability, we finally become willing to look up.

The invitation in both of these stories is the same. Stop fighting. Stop insisting on your own way, your own timeline, your own control. Drop the excuses. Drop the pride. And simply say, Lord, save me.

That prayer is not only for those who have never known God. It is for anyone who has spent any amount of time trusting in their own strength instead of his. It is a prayer that never grows old and never goes unanswered.

The hand of Jesus is never too short to reach wherever you are. No matter how deep the water, no matter how dark the place, grace reaches down. And it pulls you up.

Up Next
From this Collection: Blog
Currently Reading
August 11, 2026 • 5 Minute Read
When God Sends the Fish: What Stubbornness and Surrender Teach Us About Grace
There is a particular kind of stubbornness that most of us recognize in ourselves, even if we would rather not admit it. It shows up when we grip the steering wheel a little tighter and insist we know the way, even as the road grows unfamiliar. It shows up when the gas light comes on and we think, surely I can make it. It shows up in our relationships, our careers, our spiritual lives, and our prayers. We act first, then expect God to bless whatever we have already decided to do. The ancient story of Jonah is not simply a strange tale about a man and a large fish. It is a mirror. And if we look into it honestly, most of us will recognize the face staring back. Running in the Wrong Direction Jonah was a prophet, a man who heard from God. And yet when God called him to go to Nineveh, a city full of people Jonah considered enemies, he turned and went the opposite direction. He did not just hesitate or delay. He boarded a ship headed as far from his calling as the known world would allow. His refusal was not born of ignorance. It was born of pride and prejudice. He knew what God wanted. He simply decided that God was wrong about who deserved mercy. The storm that followed was not random bad weather. The sailors on that ship eventually understood something supernatural was at work. And Jonah, to his credit in that moment, admitted the truth. The storm was his fault. He was thrown overboard, and a great fish swallowed him whole. What happens next is remarkable. From inside the belly of the fish, in a place the scriptures describe as the realm of the dead, Jonah prays. Not a polished, formal prayer. A waterlogged, desperate cry from a man who has run out of options. He says in Jonah 2 that when his life was fading away, he remembered the Lord, and his prayer reached God's holy temple. Even there, in the dark and the stench and the impossibility of the moment, God heard him. The fish, it turns out, was not a punishment. It was a rescue. Jonah should have drowned. Instead, he was carried. God would rather send a disruptive, uncomfortable, even terrifying mercy than watch someone sail quietly into their own destruction. Eyes on the Storm The Gospel of Matthew gives us a companion story in Peter walking on water. The disciples are in a boat at night, being battered by waves, when they see Jesus walking toward them on the sea. Peter, in a moment of extraordinary courage and faith, asks Jesus to call him out onto the water. Jesus says one word: come. And Peter goes. He actually steps out of the boat and walks on water toward Jesus. This is not a small thing. This is faith in action, the holy kind of stubbornness that refuses to stay safe when Jesus is calling you forward. But then Peter looks around. He sees the wind. He feels the waves. He becomes suddenly, acutely aware that he is a human being standing on water in the middle of a storm, and human beings do not do that. And he begins to sink. The Greek word used in Matthew 14 for his sinking describes being pulled down into the depths, swallowed by the waves. In an instant, Peter goes from walking on water to drowning. Not because he lacked faith entirely, but because he shifted his gaze. He stopped looking at Jesus and started looking at the storm. The Same Three Words Here is what is striking when you place these two stories side by side. Jonah sinks because of deliberate rebellion. Peter sinks because of distracted self-reliance. One man is running from God. The other is reaching toward him but loses focus. The circumstances are different. The internal postures are different. And yet both men end up in the same place: underwater, out of options, desperate. And both men are saved by the same prayer. Jonah cries out to God from the belly of the fish. Peter cries out, Lord, save me. Three words. No explanation, no defense, no lengthy confession. Just a cry for help. And in both cases, God answers immediately. The fish carries Jonah to dry land. Jesus reaches out his hand and pulls Peter up before he can sink any further. Whether you sink through active rebellion or distracted pride, the grace of God reaches to the exact same depth. What Is Your Fish? It is worth sitting with an uncomfortable question. What storm or fish is present in your life right now that you have been treating as random bad luck or unfortunate circumstance? What if God is stubbornly using that disruption to stop the runaway train of your pride? Sometimes our anxieties, our burnout, our relational wreckage, our seasons of restlessness are not simply the result of a hard world. Sometimes they are the mercy of a God who loves us too much to let us keep sailing in the wrong direction. Hitting rock bottom has a way of clearing our vision. When we reach the edge of our own strength and ability, we finally become willing to look up. The invitation in both of these stories is the same. Stop fighting. Stop insisting on your own way, your own timeline, your own control. Drop the excuses. Drop the pride. And simply say, Lord, save me. That prayer is not only for those who have never known God. It is for anyone who has spent any amount of time trusting in their own strength instead of his. It is a prayer that never grows old and never goes unanswered. The hand of Jesus is never too short to reach wherever you are. No matter how deep the water, no matter how dark the place, grace reaches down. And it pulls you up.